Don’t have time for a long read? Say no more. Here are my top 5 picks for the best pencil mics in 2023. 

So, you’re on a budget (in this economy, who isn’t?) and aren’t happy with the mic you’re currently recording with. Or, you’re just putting together your very first studio setup from scratch. In any case, a pencil microphone — or a small-diaphragm condenser mic — can be a super high value-for-money investment. They’re known for their quick transient response and decent polar pattern specifications. In simpler words, they’re great for many different applications where you want precise recordings.

For this list, I’ve mostly picked out single pencil mic models priced under the $500 mark per single unit (although pencil mics are sometimes bought as a pair). Despite their relatively low price, all my picks are super high-quality and go toe to toe with some of the latest and greatest mics in their genre. Let’s dive right in!

1. Rode NT55

Price: $369.00

Pros

  • Backed by a 10-year warranty
  • Comes with a sturdy metal box for safe and easy storage
  • The amp offers transformerless output

Cons

  • One of its capsules may sound too bright for some

Let’s start with the Rode NT55. This one can easily be a potential addition to your mic locker since it simply checks all the right boxes. Plus, it comes from Rode which is one of my favorite brands when it comes to recording equipment — especially for value seekers like myself! This particular model comes with two interchangeable capsules (NT45-O and NT45-C), one yielding an omnidirectional response with the other providing a cardioid polar pattern respectively. 

The latter is designed to have a lower end which helps relieve the bass boost signals. It especially comes in handy to offset the proximity effect when you use it to close-mic a source. The NT45-C, on the other hand, sounds pretty bright (without coming off too harsh) for the higher ends. 

The NT45-O has a pretty flat response, though with a decent bottom-end. Its higher end is deliberately tuned to be exaggerated to bring up its brightness for setups where it’s used from afar. You might not like the brightness if you use it from a short distance, so you might have to make some positioning compromises to get the right results. But hey, I’m just being nitpicky at this point thanks to the technical geek in me. You might not even notice anything wrong! 

Overall, both capsules work together to offer incredibly steady polar patterns throughout the frequency response range. The mics amp is built from a JFET low-noise design that outputs without a transformer. The crispness of the amplifier is a hidden yet key factor in the NT55’s design as it lets each capsule shine with precise transient response!

The mic’s body also comprises two HPFs (high-pass filters) and two pads that make it more versatile. The HPFs are great at muting out all the random vibration and unavoidable handling noises. Pads play an equally important role of minimizing distortion, allowing the mic to handle louder sources well.

According to Rode themselves, the recommended applications of this particular model include live performances, recording drum overheads, acoustic instruments, live performances, and cymbals. So, if you plan on doing that with your new mic, the NT55 is highly recommended. You can place your order here.

2. AKG C 451 B

Price: $440.00

Pros

  • Exceptional sound quality with remarkable detail and clarity.
  • Versatile with switchable pre-attenuation pad and high-pass filter.
  • Sleek and compact design, ideal for studio and on-location recordings.

Con

  • Sensitive to handling noise; requires careful handling and shock mount.

Next up, we have the AKG C 451 B. First and foremost, the sound quality on this mic is simply outstanding. Whether you’re recording your voice, percussion, or musical instruments this mic truly shines and captures every nuance with precision. The audio fidelity is top-notch, and you’ll definitely notice the difference it makes in your recordings.

It comes with a switchable pre-attenuation pad and high-pass filter, which gives you added flexibility when capturing sound. The pre-attenuation pad allows you to handle high sound pressure levels without any distortion, which is great for recording loud sources like drums or guitar amps. The high-pass filter helps to reduce unwanted low-frequency rumble or proximity effect, ensuring a cleaner recording.

I also love the sleek and compact design of the microphone. It’s light and nimble, so it’s a convenient choice for studio and on-location recordings alike. The C 451 B also comes with a handy carrying case, providing protection during transport and storage. 

Now, let’s talk about the minor drawbacks. While the AKG C 451 B is undoubtedly an exceptional microphone, it does have a few limitations. Additionally, some users have mentioned that the microphone is sensitive to handling noise, so it’s essential to use a shock mount or a sturdy microphone stand to minimize any unwanted vibrations.

You can check it out here.

3. Shure KSM137

Price: $349.00

Pros

  • Versatile microphone for various recording applications and sound sources.
  • Low self-noise for capturing clean and transparent recordings.
  • Solid build quality and included a protective pouch for durability and convenience.

Con

  • Directional cardioid pickup pattern requires careful positioning for off-axis rejection.

At number 3, we have the Shure KSM137. What I love the most about this mic is its versatility. It’s like having multiple microphones in one! It handled different sound sources with ease, adapting well to most types of environments. Whether I was in the studio or capturing a live performance, the KSM137 delivered consistently excellent results. Its wide frequency response ensured that I captured every nuance of the audio, from the delicate highs to the rich lows, creating a balanced and full-bodied sound.

The KSM137 incorporates an electret capsule with a 2.5 μm diaphragm made of Mylar layered with 24 karat gold. Yep, you read that right! And that’s not just a marketing gimmick. This design ensures exceptional response to quick changes in sound, a broad frequency range, and a reliably consistent cardioid polar pattern. The recordings sound natural, transparent, and full of life. And that holds true for even capturing something as low-profile as room ambience! 

As for the mic’s build-quality, it feels solid and well-built, giving me confidence in its durability. It also comes with a handy protective pouch. It’s these little touches that make using the KSM137 a pleasure.

Now, let’s talk about one minor consideration. The KSM137 is a cardioid microphone. While this directional characteristic is great for isolating the desired sound source, it’s important to position the microphone correctly to avoid any unintentional off-axis sound pickup.

Overall, the Shure KSM137 is an impressive microphone that adds to the versatility and provides exceptional sound quality. Its ability to capture audio with accuracy and detail is truly remarkable, and its solid build ensures it will be a reliable companion in any recording situation. Give it a try, and you’ll probably be just as taken aback by the performance as I was! You can check it out here.

4. Avantone Pro CK-1

Price: $119.00

Pros

  • Exceptional value for its affordable price.
  • Impressive sound reproduction with accuracy and detail.
  • Versatility with interchangeable capsules for different recording scenarios.

Con:

  • Can be sensitive to plosive sounds; may require a pop filter.

While all the mics on this list are priced under $500, many young beginners, hobbyists, and students can’t spare that much cash for just one component of their recording setup. If you can relate, I’ve included the Avantone Pro CK-1 in this list just for you! You can get your hands on it from Amazon for just $119, making it the cheapest option on my list today.

Now, the price might cause you to expect very little from the CK-1. That was the case for me at least, but not for very long. The sound of this little guy made me genuinely curious as to how it manages to undercut the market so hard in terms of price. But it does, and earns a well-deserved spot on my list of personal favorites! 

And unlike most other mics on this list, this mic has not one, not two, but three interchangeable capsules. Now that’s value! Whether you need a cardioid, omnidirectional, or hypercardioid polar pattern, this microphone has got you covered. You have the freedom to experiment and tailor the microphone’s characteristics to suit your specific recording needs. This flexibility is particularly beneficial for those working in various recording environments or needing different polar patterns for different sound sources. The ability to swap capsules effortlessly gives you greater control over your recordings without having to invest in multiple microphones.

The CK-1 delivers a transparent and true-to-source sound that again belies its affordable price tag. It’s a testament to Avantone Pro’s commitment to providing high-quality audio equipment accessible to a wide range of users.

As for the little caveat that I always like to save for last, some users have mentioned that the CK-1 can be sensitive to plosive sounds, like harsh “p” and “b” sounds. While this can be easily mitigated with the use of a pop filter, it’s something to keep in mind during your recordings. Give it a look here.

5. Audix ADX51

Price: $219.00

Pros:

  • Rugged build quality for durability in demanding environments.
  • Impressive performance as drum overheads, capturing crisp cymbals and wide low-end.
  • Bright and accurate sound with excellent transient response.

Cons:

  • Limited low-end presence, which may not suit all recording situations.

To wrap up this list, I’ve got another affordable option for you — The Audix ADX51. This little mix packs a punch! It may not look as impressive in theory if you just read the spec list, but it surprised me in all the right ways. Let’s see why that happened.

First off, this mic is built like a tank. Audix really nailed it with the steel grille mesh and the precision-machined brass body. No matter how clumsy you are, you won’t be damaging this mic any time soon. I mean, it’s practically indestructible (well, maybe not bulletproof, but you get the idea).

Now, let’s talk about its sound. On paper, the frequency response graph may suggest a bright sound, but in reality, it’s far from harsh or thin. And guess what? That thinness in the low-end is even preferable in some recording scenarios. Take drum overheads, for example. The ADX51 does wonders there! The cymbals sound crisp and clean, while the low-end widens out to capture the full kit. It’s like having your drum set come to life in your recordings.

But wait, there’s more! The ADX51’s electret capsule delivers a bright and accurate sound, with impressive transient response. That’s not all. This microphone is equipped with a 10 dB pad and a high-pass filter, giving you even more flexibility when it comes to mic positioning. Close-miking? Engage those options and listen to the magic happen.

Oh, and it even comes with some cool goodies to sweeten the pot. When you get your hands on the ADX51, you’ll also find a heavy-duty snap-on mic clip, a carrying pouch (it’s like a fancy hotel for your mic), and even an external windscreen to protect it from those unexpected gusts of air. Audix really went the extra mile to ensure this mic is ready for the stage and broadcast environments. They’ve got your back, my friend.

So, if you’re looking for a mic that’s tough, versatile, and delivers fantastic results, the Audix ADX51 is definitely worth considering. Don’t let its unassuming appearance fool you—it’s a true performer that’s ready to rock the stage or shine in the studio. You can check it out here.

Final Takeaway on Low-Cost Pencil Mics

When it comes to pencil mics under $500, these top five favorites have truly impressed me. Each one brings its unique strengths and characteristics to the table, offering excellent value for your hard-earned money. Whether you’re recording vocals, acoustic instruments, or capturing the ambiance of a room, these pencil mics deliver exceptional performance without breaking the bank.

No matter which one you go for, I hope it elevates your recordings, sparks your creativity, and leaves you with a smile on your face knowing you made a fantastic investment in your audio journey. Happy recording!